Some short videos of the screen action will help you understand how the pitch information is displayed. A graph of the tune unfolds against a background of horizontal lines representing each of the 12 notes of the scale. They are labeled on the left margin, with the rather more easily grasped Hindustani notation. The seven shuddh swaras, Sa, Re, Ga, Ma, Pa, Dha, & Ni are labeled, and are drawn with solid color lines. The komal re, ga, dha, ni and tivra ma lie in-between, and are drawn with dotted lines.
Their twelve separate colors help you keep your place on the graph easily. (Imagine trying to distinguish your location amongst several dozen gray lines). Note that pairs of notes have related colors - bright green for Re, dark green for komal re; bright red for Ma, dark red for tivra ma; and so on.
The way the Carnatic notes lie against this representation is shown below.
Here's a short passage on bansuri to illustrate:
This can give you an idea of the program in action, without installing it on your computer.
[to
repeat the
video, it seems one must first click
|<
to reset the
video, or drag the pointer back to the beginning, before clicking the play
button again.]
Note
- the actual use of Tuning Meister
is much smoother than these videos can show, as the frame rate is quite
a
bit slower. This shows 16 frames a second, which captures 5 pixels per
frame. The original draws at 80 pixels per second.
You
will have to wait for the video to load completely before playing it -
this may take some time with a
slow connection.
We can easily see the melody move up and down against the lines for the swaras.
However, what we really want to see is much greater detail for the pitch of each individual note. To this end, a separate, parallel graph is added below what you have already seen. Together the pair of graphs, above and below a moveable splitter bar [1], show the pitch in several magnifications. As we have seen, the upper part of the display gives a picture of the tune it hears as a heavy black line against a permanent horizontal array of colored lines.
The portion of the screen below the splitter bar is a fine-tuning graph - a magnified view of the pitch of each individual note. That is, while the time axis remains the same in both the upper and lower graphs, in the lower graph the vertical direction is stretched quite a lot so that you can see the pitch in much greater detail.
The horizontal center line, with the label 0, of the
graph represents "in
tune" with the nearest note being sung, according to the scale and
pitch selected. The other labels at the left
[2]
indicate that each dashed line
represents a pitch differential of 10 cents.
The color
of the
trace of the
graph serves to
label which note of the
scale is being measured, and it
changes as the tune moves from note to note, matching the color of the
nearest line on the upper chart.
The boxes [3]
show how the same pitch space (vertical) is portrayed in both
the
lower and upper graph; the space in the upper graph, where a note is
closest to Pa than to ma or dha, is stretched vertically and fills the
height of the lower graph.
The
first box shows the tambura, aligned with the center. Then the flute
plays a Pa, whose color is brown. The boxes in the upper and in the
lower graphs cover the same pitch space - the lower graph magnifies the
space around Pa, which in the upper graph is only a few pixels high.
When the next note dha begins, the lower graph switches to its color,
dark red-purple. Then comes Ni, pale blue, which in this case happens
to be quite a bit sharper
than the note given by theorists. [A
thin black line through the trace
gives the average
value - of course in order to represent an average it
cannot start until a certain number of pixels after a new note begins]. We continue with Sa (quite a bit sharp) in
dark blue, bright green Re, greenish-yellow ga, Re again, Sa [way
better in tune], and
Ni.
Much greater pitch detail can be seen
than in
the upper graph of the overall tune. The lower graph is where you can
examine
the precision of the intonation of a recording, and with a microphone,
your own playing or singing. We
see that the first Sa is quite a bit sharp, the second one quite
precisely in tune with the tambura.
Ni
is sharp both times - probably this is the way the player has grown up
with that swara. It is quite useful to observe how consistent different
performers are, and of course to strive for greater consistency
yourself.
The final
note on this clip wanders sort of midway between Dha and dha so it
changes back and forth between two colors.
Again, the key to
understanding the lower graph is that the color
of the trace signifies the
note
being
graphed. The lower graph moves between representing first one
note, then another. The color-labeling
allows a seamless graph
where time
moves across at an even pace; note names or other symbols
won’t
work
because there can’t be an interruption in the smooth
horizontal
flow of
the graph, which corresponds to the passage of time.
Indian music naturally involves lots of
gliding
between notes, fast gamakas and
so forth; all these quick ornaments, and movements in between notes,
can be seen in the trace in the upper graph. And they generally move so
fast that the lower graph becomes just a jumble of color - so you just
ignore
it for those passages. But whenever
the performer alights on a note, the lower graph will give quite
precise detail as to the subtlety of the shruti involved. We can see
that the graph is very closely aligned with the tambura. The
tambura trace seems rather vague; it may be because its sound is not so
closely recorded, but it may just be that, as a very straight sound it
makes a very narrow, non-wiggly line and is a bit hidden behind the
black center line. And you will usually
find
that even a fixed sound like the tambura or harmonium will wander a few
cents - the harmonium because of subtle changes in the bellows
pressure.
The same is true of an open violin string - different bow pressure will
change the pitch a small but easily seen amount.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Now you should try actually observing the graph for yourself, through a microphone. You can start the tuning process from Options | Tuning Graph.
You may need to
manipulate the Recording
controls
to feed the music to
the software. Most of the utility of the program takes place simply by
watching the
graph; most of the things you need to learn involve how to set
parameters appropriate to the moment, but once launched your sessions
really involve simply interacting with the pitch information, perhaps
using the
feedback it provides to sharpen your hearing and your sense of
shruti.
You will have to set some parameters. To monitor a performance you clearly need to align the graph to the singer or instrument of the moment, and to achieve this you set Options | Pitch of Sa & Range.
Note this last form of the dialog box is made quite
wide
so it can be
as shallow as possible; that allows a bit less of the tuning screen
to be hidden.
For Indian music you usually want to
accommodate the
graph to an existing sound; for instance, you are pretty much stuck
with the pitch of a harmonium, or a flute. This process is
shown
in the video below, where the shruti box is set near E. This
would
fit got instance a male vocalist with a slightly higher than normal
range, which is
often C#, the starting point in the video. Note that the line in the
Upper Graph begins as a komal ga, relative to the C#. We adjust
the slider Nearest
Piano Note to Sa
[1]
three
times to the right, bringing the reference Sa to
Re, komal re, and finally it appears as
the dark blue representing
Sa. Now it is close but it is not yet right
on the reference line; it is sharp more than 50
cents. So we raise the pitch to meet that - by moving the
slider
giving the pitch (Hz) for the corresponding
western "A"
[2]
until the blue trace sits on the exact center of the lower graph. In
this case the pitch
line was above the center, so we raised our reference pitch; had it
been below the center, we would have lowered the reference to meet the
line.
[It is helpful to know that moving the slider for the
pitch of A by one
"page" value changes it by 5 Hz, which is very close to 20 cents at 440
Hz. So we use that motion twice, to come close, before pressing an end
arrow
or the left/right
arrow key for fine
adjustment by 0.1 Hz].
[Alternatively, you might directly select the note you like to sing on, and set your shruti box pitch to lie on the center line.]
The Indian
vocal -
female or male
entry
supplied under the Instruments
menu item is just a starting point, sort of average. Some vocalists
sing several notes higher, some lower. Adjust your Sa as we have shown.
Also, you may
perhaps
sing notes lower than M or higher than P and need to adjust the Lowest
[3] and
Highest
note
[4] entries
accordingly. [The Concert Pitch
labels just give the western note names for the bottom and top
notes of the graph].
Keeping
the
Relative
Range Constant
[5]
should
always be the selection for Indian music. It will allow you to
move from one Sa to another while the relative range, from M to P will
always remain the same. If you have the program version limited to raga
performance, that control has been removed to make life simpler for
you.
In certain modes of practice it is useful to have the graph trace stop when input ceases; similar to a voice-activated recording mode. For instance you may wish to sing or play a short phrase without looking at the graph, then check to see if your sense of intonation corresponds with what the graph drew. To switch between continuous trace or input-activated start and stop, check View | Trace Continuous [or input dependent].
You won't want to have to adjust these
parameters
of Pitch of Sa & Range
every time and
so for that we turn to the Instruments
menu, where you can save and
later retrieve different settings for your work with Tuning Meister.